Being Liked Isn’t Being Trusted


Being Liked Isn’t Being Trusted

Hello Future Leaders,

Welcome back to the newsletter. Quick question before we start. Can you picture the ideal manager everyone loves? Warm, remembers your birthday, never makes anyone feel small. Now a harder one. When that manager says something will get handled, do people actually believe it?

Not always. And that quiet gap, between how much people enjoy you and how much they rely on you, is what we’re getting into today. Because somewhere early in every leadership journey, these two things get tangled up. Confusing them is one of the most expensive mistakes you can make, long before you even have a title.

The trap that feels like kindness

A lot of things you read about leadership on the internet are complete BS. A lot of you get it completely wrong. The first time people look to you for direction, the instinct is to get them to like you. It’s human. Being liked feels safe. So you soften the hard feedback until it barely lands. You let the missed deadline slide “just this once.” You make a little exception for the person you get along with. Each move feels generous in the moment.

But watch what the team learns over a few months. They learn that the standard bends if they push on it. They learn that effort is optional. They learn that your warmth is more reliable than your follow-through. The people who were already coasting relax even further. And the people who actually came to do good work quietly start wondering if they’re in the wrong place.

That’s the cruel part. The leader who tries hardest to keep everyone happy often ends up losing the exact people they most wanted to keep.

There’s a name for it

This pattern is so common that a researcher built a whole framework around it. Kim Scott, who ran teams at Google and Apple before writing about management, calls it ruinous empathy: caring about someone so much that you withhold the honest feedback they need. She argues it’s the most common mistake managers make and that it quietly causes more damage than the loud, aggressive bosses everyone complains about.

The logic is simple and a little uncomfortable. You care about the person. You don’t want to hurt their feelings. So you stay quiet, or you dress the feedback up until the real message disappears. It feels like compassion. But your silence just robbed them of the one thing that would have helped them grow. You protected their comfort today and cost them their progress for the next year.

Scott even tells a story about an employee she describes as warm, well-liked, and steadily underperforming. Because everyone liked him, nobody told him the truth, including her. By the time the problem couldn’t be ignored, the kind thing would have been to speak up months earlier. The nice thing and the kind thing had slowly become opposites.

The “um” that changed a career

Scott learned the flip side from her own boss. Early on at Google, she gave a presentation to the founders, and it went well. Afterward, Sheryl Sandberg walked her through everything she’d done right, then mentioned that she said “um” a lot. Scott brushed it off. Sandberg raised it again. Still nothing got through. So finally she said it plainly: when you say “um” every third word, it makes you sound stupid.

Harsh on paper. Scott calls it one of the kindest things anyone ever did for her. She booked the speech coach. She fixed the habit. And look closely at what Sandberg actually did, because it’s the whole lesson. She didn’t say Scott was stupid. She said the habit made her sound that way, and then she pointed straight at the fix. She cared enough to be direct, and she was specific enough to be useful. That combination is exactly what builds trust.

Comfort makes people like you, certainty makes them trust you

Being liked comes from making people comfortable. Being trusted comes from making people certain.

Certain that you mean what you say. Certain that the standard is the same for the person you love working with and the person you find difficult. Certain that when something is broken, you’ll name it, not let it sit and rot while everyone pretends not to notice.

A team that trusts you won’t always feel cozy. But they’ll always know where they stand, and that clarity is worth more than any amount of easy charm. You can be warm and honest at the same time. The leaders people trust most usually are both. Warmth without honesty is just avoidance wearing a friendly face.

Your best people are not here for comfort

This is the part worth sitting with. Your strongest people can find comfort anywhere. What they can’t find just anywhere is a place where the bar is real, because a real bar is the only thing that actually makes them better.

When you keep the standard high, you’re telling them the work matters and that they’re capable of meeting it. When you let it slide to keep the peace, you’re quietly telling them the opposite. High performers read that signal fast. And the moment they decide your standards are negotiable, they start looking for a leader whose standards aren’t.

So the accountability you’ve been avoiding to protect the relationship is the thing that protects the relationship. Not the other way around.

How to lead from trust, not approval

A few ways to make the shift, starting this week.

Separate caring from keeping people comfortable

The most caring thing you can do is tell someone the truth early, while they can still act on it. Care shows up as clarity, not leniency.

Hold the line for everyone

The fastest way to lose your best people is to make exceptions for your least accountable ones. One quiet exception tells the whole team that effort is optional. Consistency isn’t harsh. It’s fair.

Say the hard thing early, not eventually

Feedback you sit on stops being feedback. It curdles into resentment with your name attached. Early and kind beats late and loaded, every time.

Measure respect, not approval

Approval vanishes the second you stop giving people what they want. Respect gets built through consistency and honesty, and it holds even when people are briefly annoyed with you.

One thing to do before Friday

Think of the one conversation you’ve been avoiding. The feedback you keep softening, the standard you keep letting slip, and the person you keep meaning to talk to. Have it. Keep it kind, keep it specific, and point clearly at the fix.

It’ll feel like you’re risking the relationship. You’re actually building the only part of it that survives a hard day.

Being liked is pleasant. It just doesn’t hold up when things get difficult. Trust does, every single time.

Feedback

​Subscribe to participate in polls.

If you have specific feedback or anything interesting you’d like to share, please let us know by replying to this email.

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Future Leader

We are a practical leadership newsletter that helps students, fresh graduates, young professionals, and future managers build leadership skills before they get their first leadership role.

Read more from Future Leader
Give the credit away

Give the credit away Hello Future Leaders, Welcome back to the newsletter. Let’s talk about something that feels completely backwards until you watch it happen in real life. The fastest way to get credit is to give it away. It sounds like a nice motivational line. It’s actually one of the most practical career moves you’ll ever make, and there’s solid research sitting underneath it. Let’s get into why. Two managers, one win Picture two managers. Same project, same result, same meeting with...

The Small Promise You Forgot Is That Costs You

The Small Promise You Forgot Is That Costs You Hello Future Leaders, Welcome back to the newsletter where we turn everyday leadership challenges into practical skills you can use this week. Today, we're exploring how small, forgotten promises can quietly destroy trust. You'll see how three missed commitments led to an unexpected resignation, why even minor promises matter more than managers realize, and a simple three-step system to make sure your word means something to your team. The...

Working Late Is Not A Leadership Trait

Working Late Is Not A Leadership Trait Hello Future Leaders, Welcome back to the newsletter where we turn everyday leadership challenges into practical skills you can use this week. Today, we're looking at what your long working hours are quietly teaching your team. You'll discover why staying late can create pressure even when you never ask anyone else to, what research says about productivity, and four practical changes that help you lead through results rather than hours worked. Four...