Feeling Like a Fraud Means You Are Growing


Feeling Like a Fraud Means You Are Growing

Hello Future Leaders,

Welcome back to the newsletter where we turn everyday leadership challenges into practical skills you can use this week.

Today, we're tackling that uncomfortable feeling of being underqualified for your role. You'll learn why self-doubt doesn't always mean poor performance, how one new manager earned trust by admitting what she didn't know, and three simple ways to build confidence before you actually feel it.

When does the faking-it feeling stop?

You've probably asked yourself this one in the car park before work. Maybe in the shower. Possibly at 3am.

You got the promotion. People call you by the new title. They wait for you to decide things. And a quiet voice keeps saying that any minute now someone's going to notice you have no idea what you're doing.

So when does that voice go away?

The honest answer

It usually doesn't go away first. It goes quiet after you've done the job for a while, and it comes back the next time you step up.

Self-help posts on the internet tend to skip this.

Impostor feelings have been studied since psychologists Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes named the pattern in 1978, and they're far from rare. A 2020 systematic review of the research found prevalence estimates running anywhere between 9% and 82%, depending on how researchers measured it. The spread tells you how slippery the thing is. The upper end tells you you're in crowded company.

What makes it worse in a new role is timing. You're judging yourself against the person you were a year ago, while your team is judging you on what they see this week. Those two pictures rarely match when you're learning fast.

Think about the last time you were new at something and good at it at the same time. A new sport, a new language, a new instrument.

You probably felt clumsier in month two than in week one, because by month two you could finally see how much you didn't know. Your skill had grown. Your sense of the gap had grown faster.

Maya's first all-hands

Maya was promoted to engineering manager in June, over the eleven people she'd been sitting next to for two years.

Her first team meeting in the new role was on a Tuesday. She'd written out every word.

Halfway through, Tomás asked whether the Q3 roadmap was locked. It wasn't, and Maya didn't know who'd decide. She felt her face go hot and said, "Good question. I don't know yet. I'll find out and post the answer in the channel by Thursday."

She spent the whole afternoon convinced she'd blown it.

Two weeks later, her own manager forwarded some feedback from the team. Tomás had written that Maya was "the first manager who says when she doesn't know something." He meant it as praise.

The harder version of the question

Here's the question underneath the first one. If I still feel like a fraud, am I actually doing the job badly?

Not necessarily, and there's decent evidence for that.

MIT researcher Basima Tewfik studied people with frequent workplace impostor thoughts across several settings, including an investment firm and doctors in training. Those people were rated as more interpersonally effective by others, because they became more focused on other people, asked more questions and listened harder. And their performance didn't suffer for it.

Tewfik adds a fair warning. Her work also found the feeling dented people's self-esteem, so nobody should go looking for it. Still, the doubt you're carrying is a poor guide to how you're coming across.

Three answers you can use

You can't wait to feel confident before acting like a manager. So act first, in small, visible ways.

Decide something small every day, out loud. Who owns the bug, which meeting gets cancelled, what goes in the update. People who feel like frauds often stall on decisions because each one feels like a test. Small decisions made in the open build a track record faster than big ones made in private.

Say "I don't know yet" with a date on it. "I'll find out by Thursday" turns a gap into a promise you can keep. Maya's sentence did more for her credibility than any of her prepared slides.

Keep a done list. Every Friday, write three things you did that week that your old job wouldn't have asked of you. Dan, a first-time sales director, started doing this in his second month. By month four he had 40 lines of proof that he was doing the job, which helped on the nights his brain insisted otherwise.

Dan's list would bore anyone else. One line just said, "Told the Leeds client no on the discount, kept the account." On a bad Sunday evening, though, it was a page of evidence written in his own handwriting, and that's hard to argue with.

The one that matters most

Ask your manager one question this week: "What did you see in me that made you put me in this role?"

It might feel uncomfortable, but you're not fishing for compliments. You're asking for evidence of strengths you may have overlooked.

Write down the answer. Keep it somewhere you can find it the next time you start questioning whether you belong.

And remember, confidence often arrives after you've done the difficult thing a few times, not before. You can make good decisions, ask useful questions, and earn people's trust while still feeling uncertain.

You don't have to feel ready every morning to be good at your job.

Feedback

​Subscribe to participate in polls.

If you have specific feedback or anything interesting you’d like to share, please let us know by replying to this email.

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Future Leader

We are a practical leadership newsletter that helps students, fresh graduates, young professionals, and future managers build leadership skills before they get their first leadership role.

Read more from Future Leader
Give the credit away

Give the credit away Hello Future Leaders, Welcome back to the newsletter. Let’s talk about something that feels completely backwards until you watch it happen in real life. The fastest way to get credit is to give it away. It sounds like a nice motivational line. It’s actually one of the most practical career moves you’ll ever make, and there’s solid research sitting underneath it. Let’s get into why. Two managers, one win Picture two managers. Same project, same result, same meeting with...

Being Liked Isn’t Being Trusted

Being Liked Isn’t Being Trusted Hello Future Leaders, Welcome back to the newsletter. Quick question before we start. Can you picture the ideal manager everyone loves? Warm, remembers your birthday, never makes anyone feel small. Now a harder one. When that manager says something will get handled, do people actually believe it? Not always. And that quiet gap, between how much people enjoy you and how much they rely on you, is what we’re getting into today. Because somewhere early in every...

The Small Promise You Forgot Is That Costs You

The Small Promise You Forgot Is That Costs You Hello Future Leaders, Welcome back to the newsletter where we turn everyday leadership challenges into practical skills you can use this week. Today, we're exploring how small, forgotten promises can quietly destroy trust. You'll see how three missed commitments led to an unexpected resignation, why even minor promises matter more than managers realize, and a simple three-step system to make sure your word means something to your team. The...